What Role Does Breed Play in Dog Bite Lawsuits?

  • Home
  • What Role Does Breed Play in Dog Bite Lawsuits?
What Role Does Breed Play in Dog Bite Lawsuits?

What Role Does Breed Play in Dog Bite Lawsuits?

Dog bites can cause severe injuries, and victims often seek legal recourse through personal injury claims. However, one question that frequently arises in dog bite lawsuits is whether the breed of the dog influences the outcome. While breed-specific laws exist in some areas, the role of breed in legal cases is not always straightforward. This blog explores how dog breeds factor into dog bite lawsuits and how injury law experts approach these cases.

The Legal Landscape of Dog Bite Lawsuits

Dog bite injury lawsuits are rooted in personal injury law, where the injured party can seek compensation for medical bills, pain, and suffering, and lost wages. Dog owners are typically held responsible for their pets’ actions under one of two legal doctrines: strict liability or negligence. In strict liability states, owners are liable for dog bites, regardless of the dog’s behavior or whether the owner was negligent. In negligence states, the plaintiff must prove that the owner was careless in some way, such as failing to properly restrain the dog or prevent the attack.

As injury law experts know, these cases often hinge on proving that the dog bite was foreseeable and that the owner should have taken precautions. However, breed can sometimes complicate the issue.

Breed-Specific Laws: Do They Make a Difference?

In some areas, there are laws that specifically target certain dog breeds. These laws are commonly referred to as “breed-specific legislation” (BSL). BSL often bans or restricts breeds that are considered dangerous, such as pit bulls, Rottweilers, and Doberman Pinschers. Proponents of these laws argue that certain breeds are more likely to cause severe injuries, while critics contend that breed alone is not a reliable indicator of aggression.

For example, some cities or counties may have laws that require owners of certain breeds to carry higher insurance or implement additional safety measures. These laws can make it easier for an injury settlement lawyer to prove liability in a dog bite case if the dog involved is on the restricted breed list.

However, the existence of BSL does not mean that a dog breed automatically determines the outcome of a dog bite lawsuit. Courts generally focus on the behavior of the individual dog and whether the owner took appropriate steps to prevent harm.

The Role of Dog Breed in Liability

Even in the absence of breed-specific laws, the breed of the dog can still play a role in determining liability in some cases. For instance, if a breed is known for being aggressive or difficult to control, and the owner failed to take precautions, a court might find that the owner’s negligence was a contributing factor.

That being said, courts rarely make breed the sole determining factor in a dog bite lawsuit. Factors like the dog’s history of aggression, the victim’s behavior at the time of the bite, and the owner’s knowledge of the dog’s temperament are often more significant. For example, a dog’s past history of biting or showing aggressive behavior can be an important piece of evidence in a lawsuit, regardless of the breed.

In some cases, the actions of the victim may also come into play. If the victim was provoking the dog or trespassing on the owner’s property, the owner might argue that they were not liable for the injury.

Why Breed Is Not Always a Deciding Factor?

While certain breeds may be stereotyped as more dangerous, studies have shown that factors such as the dog’s upbringing, training, and socialization are far more significant in determining behavior. A well-trained dog of any breed is less likely to bite than a poorly trained one, regardless of breed.

This is why many injury law experts advise focusing on the specific circumstances surrounding the bite rather than the dog’s breed. For instance, if a pit bull attacks, it may be easier to assume aggression based on the breed’s reputation. However, if the dog was provoked or had a history of being well-behaved, it could significantly impact the case.

Moreover, breed-specific legislation does not always hold up in court. Many legal experts believe that breed bans are ineffective in preventing dog attacks and may unfairly target certain breeds. In fact, several studies have shown that breeds such as the Labrador Retriever, which is often considered friendly, are just as likely to bite as more aggressive breeds.

Determining Negligence in Dog Bite Cases

When it comes to dog bite lawsuits, proving negligence is often more important than proving breed-related aggression. Dog owners have a responsibility to prevent harm by ensuring that their dogs are properly contained, restrained, and trained. In cases where a dog has previously shown aggression, the owner may be considered negligent if they fail to take extra precautions.

A lawyer will often focus on gathering evidence about the dog’s behavior and the owner’s actions leading up to the incident. Was the dog previously aggressive? Was the owner aware of the dog’s tendencies? Did the owner take reasonable precautions, such as keeping the dog on a leash or fencing in their yard? These questions are more crucial than the dog’s breed in most cases.

The Importance of Dog’s History

One of the most critical factors in a dog bite lawsuit is the history of the dog. If the dog has previously bitten someone or shown signs of aggression, this can provide a strong argument for liability. This is true regardless of the breed.

For instance, if a dog with a history of aggression bites a person, it strengthens the case for the plaintiff. In these situations, an injury settlement lawyer will work to prove that the owner failed to act on previous warnings and should be held accountable for the dog’s actions.

On the other hand, if the dog has no history of aggression, the case may be more difficult to win, as the owner might not have been aware of any potential risk.

In Conclusion

If you’ve been injured in a dog bite incident, let The Bendell Law Firm, PLLC help you take the first step toward justice. Start with a complimentary consultation, where we’ll listen to your story and provide tailored legal guidance. You won’t pay a dime unless we win your case, thanks to our contingency fee approach. Our team is available 24/7, ready to answer your questions and keep you informed every step of the way. With a focus on the latest legal strategies, we’ll work to secure the best possible outcome for you. Contact us today and put experience on your side.

 

 

 

  • Share on: